Question 1

What should commercial property due diligence include?

Accepted Answer

Commercial property due diligence should help you understand the visible physical condition of the asset, immediate and near-term repair needs, deferred maintenance, accessibility concerns, major system performance, probable capital costs, and any conditions that may warrant specialist evaluation.

The appropriate scope depends on the property and the decision being made. A commercial real-estate transaction, a renovation project, and a long-term capital plan may require different levels of review.

Question 2

Which type of assessment do I need: a PCA, an FCA, or an accessibility assessment?

Accepted Answer

The right assessment depends on the questions you need answered.

Property Condition Assessment (PCA): Commonly used for commercial real-estate transactions, financing decisions, and underwriting.
Facility Condition Assessment (FCA): Used to support ongoing asset management, maintenance planning, and capital prioritization.
Accessibility Assessment: Focuses on potential barriers and the accessibility standards that may apply to a facility.

Some properties benefit from a coordinated scope that includes more than one type of evaluation. The ASTM E2018-24 guide for Property Condition Assessments describes a baseline PCA process for commercial properties.

Question 3

What is the difference between a Property Condition Assessment and a Facility Condition Assessment?

Accepted Answer

A Property Condition Assessment typically supports a commercial property transaction, financing decision, or underwriting process. It identifies visible physical deficiencies and provides opinions of probable costs within an agreed scope.

A Facility Condition Assessment is generally used to support longer-term ownership decisions, including maintenance planning, capital budgeting, and the prioritization of repairs or replacements across a facility or portfolio.

The two assessments can overlap, but the business decision behind the assessment is different. ASTM describes its current E2018-24 PCA guide as a baseline process. ASTM is also developing separate Facility Condition Assessment guidance focused on asset management, capital planning, and maintenance-management applications.

Question 4

Does a PCA include an ADA or accessibility assessment?

Accepted Answer

A baseline PCA should not automatically be treated as a comprehensive accessibility assessment. Depending on the agreed scope, a PCA may identify visible accessibility concerns or include a limited screening. A dedicated accessibility assessment may be appropriate when the property type, renovation plans, transaction risk, or known conditions require a closer review.

The ASTM E2018-24 guide describes a voluntary baseline PCA process. Accessibility requirements can involve separate federal, state, and local standards. The 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design provide federal scoping and technical requirements for covered facilities.

Question 5

What can a standard PCA miss if the scope is too limited?

Accepted Answer

A standard PCA focuses on visible conditions within the agreed scope. It may not identify concealed conditions, issues requiring destructive testing, detailed code-compliance concerns, environmental conditions, or problems that require specialized investigation.

A PCA can help reveal where deeper evaluation may be warranted, but it should not be treated as a guarantee that every issue has been identified. The ASTM E2018-24 guide states that a PCA is not intended to be technically exhaustive and cannot wholly eliminate uncertainty regarding physical deficiencies or building-system performance.

Question 6

Does passing a local building inspection mean a property is ADA compliant?

Accepted Answer

No. A certificate of occupancy or local building inspection does not automatically confirm compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act.

The ADA Standards apply nationally in addition to applicable state and local accessibility requirements. The U.S. Access Board guidance on using the ADA Standards states that an occupancy permit or building inspection does not ensure ADA compliance.

Question 7

Do older commercial buildings have to meet current ADA accessibility requirements?

Accepted Answer

Older buildings are not automatically exempt from ADA requirements. The obligations depend on the facility, how it is used, whether alterations are planned, and which accessibility requirements apply.

For businesses that are open to the public, the ADA may require architectural barriers in existing facilities to be removed when doing so is readily achievable. Readily achievable means that the change is easy to accomplish without much difficulty or expense. The requirement is evaluated based on factors such as the size and resources of the business.

Review the U.S. Department of Justice guidance for businesses that are open to the public under ADA Title III and the official ADA Standards for Accessible Design.

Question 8

Who is responsible for ADA compliance in a leased commercial property: the landlord or the tenant?

Accepted Answer

For a leased space that operates as a place of public accommodation, both the landlord and the tenant may have responsibilities under ADA Title III.

A lease can allocate specific compliance responsibilities between the parties. However, that agreement does not eliminate the underlying ADA obligations that apply to the property.

The U.S. Department of Justice explains landlord and tenant responsibilities in its ADA Title III Technical Assistance Manual.

Question 9

When do Fair Housing Act accessibility requirements apply to multifamily housing?

Accepted Answer

The Fair Housing Act includes design-and-construction accessibility requirements for covered multifamily dwellings designed and constructed for first occupancy after March 13, 1991.

Covered multifamily dwellings generally include buildings with four or more units and an elevator, as well as ground-floor units in buildings with four or more units that do not have an elevator. The specific requirements depend on the property.

Review the official HUD and Department of Justice guidance on Fair Housing Act design-and-construction requirements.

Question 10

What is the difference between ADA, Fair Housing Act, ABA, and UFAS accessibility requirements?

Accepted Answer

Different accessibility requirements may apply based on the property type, use, ownership, funding source, and project circumstances.

ADA Standards: Apply to covered state and local government facilities, public accommodations, and commercial facilities.
Fair Housing Act: Includes accessibility requirements for covered multifamily housing designed and constructed for first occupancy after March 13, 1991.
Architectural Barriers Act (ABA): Applies to facilities designed, built, altered, or leased with federal funds or leased by federal agencies.
Uniform Federal Accessibility Standards (UFAS): Remain relevant in certain federal and federally funded contexts.

A property may be subject to more than one requirement. Review the official ADA Accessibility Standards, ABA Standards, UFAS standards, and HUD Fair Housing Act guidance.

Question 11

Can due diligence identify repair costs before I purchase a property?

Accepted Answer

A well-scoped due diligence assessment can identify visible deficiencies, prioritize immediate and near-term repairs, and provide opinions of probable costs to support planning, underwriting, and negotiations.

It cannot eliminate every unknown, particularly when a concern is concealed or requires testing. The goal is to understand what is visible, what may require action, and where additional investigation may be justified before the transaction moves forward.

The ASTM E2018-24 guide describes a baseline PCA process that includes opinions of costs for suggested remedies of observed physical deficiencies.

Question 12

When should a PCA lead to a more detailed specialist assessment?

Accepted Answer

A more detailed evaluation may be appropriate when the PCA identifies a condition that falls outside a baseline review or requires deeper technical analysis.

Examples may include structural distress, recurring water intrusion, building-envelope concerns, aging mechanical or electrical systems, elevator or escalator performance issues, accessibility barriers, or conditions that may require testing or repair design.

The ASTM E2018-24 guide recognizes that users may need to expand the assessment scope based on the property, the purpose of the PCA, and their risk tolerance.

Question 13

Is a PCA the same as a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment?

Accepted Answer

No. A PCA and a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment address different risks.

Property Condition Assessment: Evaluates the visible physical condition of improvements at a commercial property.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment: Evaluates environmental conditions and potential liability for contamination.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency explains that All Appropriate Inquiries are used to evaluate environmental conditions and assess potential liability for contamination. The EPA recognizes ASTM E1527-21 as a standard that can be used to satisfy the All Appropriate Inquiries requirements.

Question 14

Can Walker support a property after the assessment is complete?

Accepted Answer

Yes. An assessment is often the starting point, not the final step.

When findings require additional action, Walker can help determine the appropriate next move. That may include a more detailed specialist evaluation, additional testing, remediation planning, capital-priority refinement, or repair design.

The goal is not simply to document conditions. It is to help you understand which findings matter, what should happen next, and how to move forward with confidence.

Question 15

What information should I gather before scheduling a due diligence assessment?

Accepted Answer

Useful information may include:

Property address, building type, age, and square footage
Existing drawings, prior reports, and available maintenance records
Known deficiencies or recurring issues
Renovation, acquisition, refinancing, or repositioning plans
Transaction deadlines and access limitations
Accessibility concerns or prior complaints
Desired capital-planning horizon
Any systems or conditions that may require specialist review

Walker can help define the appropriate scope based on the property and the decisions you need to make.

Know What You’re Taking On

What do you need to understand?

What decision are you preparing to make?

How broad is the property question?

What do you need from the assessment?

Which assessment fits your priorities?

Property Condition Assessment

Facility Condition Assessment

Accessibility Assessment

Coordinated Scope

A Clearer View Before You Move Forward

Accessibility Consulting

Facility Condition Assessments

Property Condition Assessments

Know What Needs Attention. Then Know What Comes Next.

Contact Us About Due Diligence

Questions about Due Diligence